Poets logo

Rotten Fruit in the Fridge

I Don't Know Why I Keep Looking

By Tim CarmichaelPublished 9 months ago 1 min read
Runner-Up in I Didn’t Say That Out Loud Challenge
Photo created by FreePik

There’s a plum in the back of the fridge

that’s been there for three months.

I haven’t thrown it out.

I open the door, look at it,

close the door.

I don’t know what that says about me

but it says something.

I still Google people I used to love

just to make sure they didn’t die

without telling me.

Not because I’d do anything about it.

Just because I want to know

if I’m still allowed to be angry.

When I say I’m tired,

I don’t mean sleepy.

I mean I’m worn thin from holding in

every little thing I think would make people leave.

The real me is ugly in places.

Like a house with no couch.

Like a voicemail you delete before the beep.

Sometimes I pretend I’m on a talk show

explaining my side of the story.

Imaginary applause.

Imaginary understanding.

In real life, I nod a lot.

People like that about me.

I get jealous of people who cry in public.

Their faces go red and wet,

and nobody calls them dramatic.

I once bit my cheek so hard

to stop myself from sobbing at a Denny’s

that I tasted metal

for the rest of the night.

I tell people I don’t want kids.

But the truth is

I don’t trust myself not to mess one up.

I yell at dogs when I’m tired.

I’ve ignored texts from people who said “I need you.”

I think I believe in God,

but only on elevators.

My voicemail is full.

Not with messages—

with the pressure of pretending

someone might leave one.

Some nights I lie on the floor

like a crime scene

and wait for a reason to get up.

None comes.

Still, I brush my teeth.

Still, I feed the cat.

And tomorrow

I’ll open the fridge,

see the plum,

close it again.

Free Verse

About the Creator

Tim Carmichael

I am an Appalachian poet and cookbook author. I write about rural life, family, and the places I grew up around. My poetry and essays have appeared in Beautiful and Brutal Things, My latest book. Check it out on Amazon

https://a.co/d/537XqhW

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments (14)

Sign in to comment
  • Sean A.7 months ago

    Those lines on god and elevators was a great blend of dark truth and humor.

  • F. M. Rayaan8 months ago

    This was quietly brilliant, Tim. The plum, the elevator God, the full voicemail with no messages—every line hit like a whisper you can’t un-hear. It’s raw, funny, and devastating all at once. Congrats on the well-deserved runner-up spot 👏🫀

  • Joe O’Connor8 months ago

    Excellent Tim- this is searingly honest, open to the point where readers will catch something they can empathise with, and the tone is on point. "I think I believe in God, but only on elevators." favourite line for me.

  • Well deserved Runner Up placing… I love the way you interwove commonplace occurrences with deeper issues.

  • Lamar Wiggins8 months ago

    Congrats, Tim! A very unique entry! So glad it was recognized!

  • Wooohooooo congratulations on your win! 🎉💖🎊🎉💖🎊

  • A. J. Schoenfeld8 months ago

    I love how you took something so mundane and turned it into a metaphor for something huge and overwhelming. Also, sometimes I pretend I'm on a talk show too. Give me a mic so everyone has to listen. Perhaps that's why we write instead. Congratulations on your Runner Up!

  • Julie Lacksonen8 months ago

    Yay!! Congratulations! This is stunning. What an accomplishment!

  • JBaz8 months ago

    Wow There is something special about this piece Congratulations

  • Imola Tóth8 months ago

    Congratulations on your placement! 🎉🎉

  • Tiffany Gordon9 months ago

    Superbly-written & touching... 🙏🏾Praying

  • Mother Combs9 months ago

    I've done that, and didn't even feel guilty about it

  • L.I.E9 months ago

    Wow, so real confession. Some are relatable. Sounds like depression. Excellent poem.

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.